FLYING WITH FLAPS

Jul 09, 2013 8 Comments by

Sooner or later, many RC modelers try their hand at a scale subject, and since most full-size aircraft use flaps, their scale model should include them as well. A scale model with the flaps fully deployed is an impressive sight. This will most likely be the pilot’s first exposure to flaps since most of our sport models don’t use them. Flaps are terrific; they can transform that hot P-51 from a bear to a pussycat on landing. They can, on the other hand, present problems if misused.

This impressive Westland Wyvern is the work of David Wigley. The model weighs 50 pounds and features scale Fowler flaps, which increase both drag and wing area when deployed.

Next time you fly in a large commercial airliner, take note of the transformation of the wing prior to takeoff and landing. Airliners or other fast aircraft achieve their eye-popping performance through the use of small, thin wings. The problem with this type of wing is that they stall at high speeds and consequently the takeoff and landing speeds are also very high. When flaps are lowered they change the wing’s lift and drag characteristics and lower the stall speed.

By changing the camber of the wing, the lift and drag are increased for a given airspeed. As a result of these changes the aircraft can land at a slower airspeed, fly a steeper landing approach and use more power on landing, which is a good thing if you have to ìgo-aroundî with your model.


The BH Models Trojan slows to a crawl with flaps deployed.

FLAP VARIETIES

There are four basic types of flaps: plain, split, Fowler and slotted. The plain flap is simply a hinged portion of the trailing edge. Split type flaps are hinged at the bottom of the wing and create much more drag than plain flaps. The slotted flap is similar to a plain flap, but has a slot between the wing’s trailing edge and the flap. The air passing through the slot delays the airflow separation and creates a greater increase in lift with a smaller increase in drag than a plain or split flap. Fowler flaps extend aft and down increasing the wings area and provide large increases in lift with a minimum of drag.

Do

  •  Learn how your plane reacts to flaps at a safe altitude before attempting the first landing.
  •  Reduce the throttle to around 1/3 and let the plane slow before dropping the flaps.
  •  If used for takeoff, use only partial flaps.
  •  Adjust the power to maintain the approach path. Flaps add drag and require more power.
  •  Add power on a go-around and begin a climbout before retracting flaps.

Don’t

  •  Deploy flaps at high speed. The flaps may depart the wings or cause serious structural or servo damage.
  •  Use flaps on the first takeoff and test flight. You must first determine how much deflection is correct for your model.
  •  Use full flaps on takeoff. This adds a lot of drag.
  •  Let the plane balloon and lose its airspeed. Adjust the elevator to keep the proper approach path.
  •  Retract flaps when low and slow or you could settle onto the runway.

FLAPS ALSO IMPART A LARGE STRUCTURAL LOAD ON THE PLANE AND SHOULD ONLY BE USED AT A LOWER AIRSPEED

 

Fowler flaps move rearward and downward increasing the wing area and curvature.

Slotted flaps allow high-energy air to flow from underneath the wing up and over the flap to help prevent airflow separation.

Plain flaps lower the wing’s trailing edge increasing its curvature and, therefore, its lift.

Split flaps generate a lot of drag by disturbing the airflow on the underside of the wing.

Deflecting flaps will cause a twisting action to the airplanes’ wing. The type of flap as well as the wing’s design will determine the amount of twisting action, with the split flap generating the least amount. Deploying the flaps may result in the plane pitching up or pitching down. The elevator must be used to compensate and keep the plane on the desired approach path. Another characteristic of flaps is that the first half of the flap’s deflection results in a greater increase in lift while the second half results in a greater increase in drag. Flaps also impart a large structural load on the plane and should only be used at a lower airspeed. Full-size planes have their air speed indicators marked for safe flap operating range.

 

The Top Flite B-25 Mitchell bomber has inboard and outboard flaps and lands like a trainer.


Nick Ziroli greases another landing with the help of the effective flaps on his Skyraider.

FLYING WITH FLAPS
Since every aircraft reacts differently to flaps, it’s important to learn how yours reacts before committing to landing. The safest way is to do a no-flap takeoff and fly your model around to get comfortable with it. At a safe height, reduce the throttle to about 1/3 and let the plane slow down. Next, add Ω flaps and see what your plane does. If it balloons (pitches nose-up), apply some down-elevator to help maintain the airspeed. Once the plane is under control again, add full flaps and be prepared to adjust the elevator pressure on the stick. You may be surprised how much elevator it takes to compensate for full flap deflection and how much the plane will slow down. With today’s radio systems, it’s easy to program a mix for the proper amount of elevator trim when the flaps are dropped. This will greatly ease the pilot’s workload.

Once you are comfortable with flying the plane with the flaps down, it’s time for the landing. If you have your flaps set up to drop in increments, such as a dial or slider switch, add about 10 degrees on downwind after the plane passes your position and then add about 20 to 25 degrees on base leg. After turning, add full flaps and use power to adjust the flight path. Remember, you will need more power with flaps and the approach descent rate will be steeper. With a little practice, you will be rewarded with picture-perfect landings.

Since flaps provide more lift at slower airspeeds, you must be aware that when you retract them in-flight you will lose the lift and the plane could sink. For this reason, if you must do a go-around, make sure you increase power before retracting the flaps. Failure to do so could place your plane very close to stall speed before you can accelerate to a safe speed. This also applies to takeoffs with flaps. In most cases it is safer to take off with the flaps retracted or deflected no more than about 20 degrees. Larger deflections add more drag and can cause the plane to become airborne at too low of an airspeed.

Flying a scale model with operational flaps is a very rewarding experience. Not only do they look neat, but they also provide the same benefits as the full-size version. They take the anxiety out of landing your lead-sled WW II fighter or similar high-performance aircraft and provide a safer and more enjoyable RC experience.

FLAP ACTION

Flaps impart a tremendous load on the wing and require attention during their installation. Make sure you use enough heavy-duty hinges on each flap and a heavy-duty control horn. There are many ways to actuate the flaps, including torque tubes and bell cranks. For large, fast or heavily-loaded models, the best way is to use a servo for each flap. These planes will also benefit from the flaps being locked in the down position preventing the airstream from blowing the flap back to the up position. This basically means that the servo arm is directly in line with the flap horn at full deflection and this takes the strain away from the servo. This is accomplished by turning on the radio and selecting full down flaps and choosing a servo horn position that is in line with the horn. Now, retract the flaps and make up the linkage from the servo to the horn. The amount of flap deflection is determined by the length of the servo arm; for more flap deflection, place the linkage farther out on the arm. The use of ball links may be required for smooth action and to eliminate binding.

The modeler has several options for the transmitter flap actuation method. The least desirable is to use a two-way switch, which only results in flaps up or full down. This is not very scale-like and could result in large pitch changes when the flaps are actuated. A three-position switch will allow the use of half-flaps for more scale-like flight. A knob or slider switch is another way to go and allows an infinite number of flap settings. The only drawback is that it is sometimes difficult to tell how much flap deflection is selected.

 

Featured News, Fixed-Wing Flight School

About the author

Come fly with us! The original since 1929, we ignite our readers' passion for radio-control flight.

8 Responses to “FLYING WITH FLAPS”

  1. John R. Kilgore says:

    Looks like the caption for the plain and slotted flap illustrations are reversed. Also, in the flap action, I believe you mean servo arm instead of servo horn. Certainly, it is not clear as written.

  2. fhhuber says:

    Heavy warbirds with scale flaps its often safer to take off with 5 to 7 deg flaps than with 0. Drag added is small and this small deflection effectively adds washout making the tips stall after the center section of the wing.
    Most full scale WWII fighters specify some amount of flaps for takeoff.

    Non-scale flaperon programming on the other hand can force the tips to stall first, initiating a stall-spin-crash.

    If you have 2-way switch operation of flaps set deflection for 20 to 30 deg.

    Its a good idea to program a digital servo to slow flap deployment and retraction if you use a 2 position switch.
    (slow flap operation can be helpful with any setup)

    Digital servos programmed to 180 deg can give max hold power in both the full up and full down flap settings. :)

    On some radios mixing flaps to flaps (-50% for the below example) on a 2 position switch (mix on-off) and flaps on a 3 position switch gives 5 position flaps. (they share the center position)
    Best of both worlds. You know exactly where the flaps are (unlike a dial/slider) and are not stuck with just 2 or 3 positions.
    High rate + up = 0
    low rate + up = 25%
    centered 3 position switch = 50%
    low rate + down = 75%
    high rate + down = 100%
    I have done this with JR X9303 and Polks Tracker-III

    If in doubt set max deflection 30 deg or less. You can increase it later if desired. 30 deg is about where you start adding more drag than lift. (except split flaps where you always add more drag than lift) More than 60 deg is always useless.

  3. Terry Fender says:

    Great article and very helpful to me since I recently got a Fun Cub airborne and just completed flaps on a BF-109. Can’t wait to fly the warbird and make those hot landing a little more fun.
    Plan to use the Cub for photography and the flaps will be of great benefit for those slow passes or hovering in a slight breeze.
    Good info on the types of flaps too.
    Thanks!

  4. Tango says:

    I have a Duane Habets Air Tractor 502B, with the AXi 4130-16 Motor and the Jeti 77 Opto Advance ESC, which has a flap system very close to the Fowler flaps. They roll out and down like a roll top desk cover. I can take off with 50% flap or no flap, but I always land with at least 50% flap. I have the flaps on a 3-way switch, so position 1 is off, 2 is 50% and 3 is 100% flaps, or straight down.

    Initially, I had the flaps on the dial turn switch, but found the 3-way switch to be much quicker, since I most often used about 50% flap anyway. With the 3-way switch, I just toggle the switch and I am back to flying. I have never had a problem doing it this way.

    When the flaps are deployed, the entire aircraft raises with no noticeable change in the pitch of the aircraft! It is a beautiful thing to watch! Duane Habets REALLY KNOWS HOW TO BUILD A CROP DUSTER!!! If you keep it balanced as suggested for CG, your flaps on this Air Tractor will give you perfect scale performance!

    I love it when a plane comes together! Or was that a “PLAN”? Either way, I really love my Duane Habets Air Tractor and it is the great attention to detail in Duane’s engineering and those awesome flaps, which make it take off, fly and land so much like the full scale Air Tractor!!!

    I think the Air Tractor design would have made an awesome WWII Fighter Plane, with a few aerobatic modifications and retractable landing gear of course!

    Now before I get a bag full of boos and hisses, please know my favorite plane of all time is the F-4U Corsair and I am humbled to the depths of my heart whenever I stand next to a Corsair or the mighty sleek and gorgeous, P-51 Mustang!

    As a 100% Disabled USAF Veteran and above knee amputee, I love ALL military aircraft! I just also love the Air Tractor and the Piper Pawnee Crop Dusters and yes, I like the Ag Cat, too, but I am more of a mono wing nut!

    Is everyone calmed down now? Great! Keep your wings level and the sun on your shoulders! Above all else: HAVE FUN!!!

  5. Geoff says:

    thanks thats a bit or I should say ALOT more rc experience
    passed on

  6. Jim Braithwaite says:

    Very good article.I converted my H-9 40 size J-3 cub to a Super Cub with flaps and used one servo for each flap.Mixed flap/elevator on my Futaba 9-C and used one of the slider switches for control.The flight envelope with the flaps is awesome!The Super Cub is one of my favorite airplanes to fly. The 9-C “beeps”at half flaps.

  7. Steve Hicks says:

    Thanks for the info on flaps. I will be flying my DHC-2 Beaver by Flyzone real soon, and this will help lots. Thanks again!!

  8. Ravi Gupta says:

    Could the flaps illustrations be corrected? Slotted and plain flaps images need to be swapped.

Copyright © 2014 Air Age Media. All rights reserved.